Their Own Desire

1929

Watched

Norma Shearer got nominated for an Oscar for this, and won the Oscar for THE DIVORCEE, but it reminds me of those rare years today when an actor is nominated in the same year for both an Oscar and a Razzie. Mostly due to the terrible script, Norma Shearer is so miscast here. She plays Lally, a 20-something who is still living at home and who resents her father after he divorces her mother. It maybe would have worked if…

The Letter

1929

Liked Watched

Jeanne Engels was really great, and there's rarely a posthumous nomination that doesn't add a sense of tragedy to the film. Engels died way too young, but I'm glad she had a great showing here that proved she was a great early talent.

The Leatherneck

1929

Watched

We live in a world where The Leatherneck is an Academy Award nominee. This is the type of movie that a review is needed for, because I'm going to forget I saw it otherwise.

The Valiant

1929

Liked Watched

Absolutely horrific acting by anyone other than Paul Muni! It unironically increased my enjoyment of the movie tenfold, because some of the line delivery here might genuinely be the worst I've ever seen. I'm working on a video covering the second Oscar ceremony, and I might just make an entire montage of this film's best line deliveries, because...

Skyscraper

1928

Watched

Very minor William Boyd comedy that may have been better without William Boyd. The story was silly, but I loved all of the early scenes atop the skyscraper.

Chang: A Drama of the Wilderness

1927

Liked Watched

Man, I loved this. This is so niche; a faux-documentary showing life of Siamese tribes fending for themselves and their families within a grueling jungle. It's worth it for the shots of animals alone, which are so immensely impressive given 1927 limitations. This is truly a spectacle of a film, and it is CRIMINALLY underseen and underrated. It currently holds the distinction of being the sole documentary to be up for the Best Picture Academy Award (though it is not fully a documentary, and it was actually up for the Best Artistic Picture award only seen in the first Academy Awards; still, it's well-deserved!).

A Ship Comes In

1928

Watched

A stodgy and stilted look at immigrants and the problems they face in America. This gets silly fast, with pipe bombs and war heroes and a court case, all in a choppy 70 minutes. I didn't -hate- this, but Louise Dresser's Academy Award nomination is the only reason I watched it, and she's not anything special.

The Circus

1928

Liked Rewatched

One of the four or five best Chaplin films. I didn't appreciate this as much in previous viewings, but it's just so light and fun. Sure, it's mostly just 68 minutes of circus gags, but the gags are so good! My favorites are the lion cage and tightrope bits.

Romance

1930

Watched

Incredibly dry romance. The only interesting note really is that this is one of Greta Garbo’s earliest talking roles, but it’s not even her strongest film of the 1930 ceremony!

Coquette

1929

Watched

There’s a lot of sadness in this when you consider it was Mary Pickford’s only real recognition at an Academy Awards (not counting her lifetime achievement award). Her performance was not good at all, either. Sorry to say, Pickford fans.

The Devil's Holiday

1930

Watched

Nancy Carroll is actually surprisingly good here as a gold digger who (lamely) finds her interesting aspects reformed as she falls for a strait-laced man with no inspiring qualities. It’s very generic and not particularly memorable, but it takes place at the Grand Hotel, which proves the existence of the GHCU (Grand Hotel Cinematic Universe).

Glorious Betsy

1928

Watched

Really terrible early sound film. Conrad Nagel would get me-too'd so hard these days.