Published Updated

Sort by

Hidden Gems: Highest Rated With Less Than 15K Ratings

Sorted by average rating. Must have at least 1,000 ratings and an average rating of 3.5 or higher.

Last fully updated: 7/4/2024

UPDATE 3/25/2025: I have decided to increase the maximum rating threshold of this list to match the official Letterboxd Top 250, which requires a minimum of 15k ratings. I will slowly be adding in the newly qualifying films over the next few weeks.

There are 217 films in this list released in the 1940s.

  • Shoeshine

    171

  • La Terra Trema

    255

  • Ivan the Terrible, Part II: The Boyars' Plot

    272

  • The Set-Up

    303

  • Children of the Beehive

    385

  • Hellzapoppin'

    387

  • A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

    476

  • Panic

    549

  • Ivan the Terrible, Part I

    569

  • Cluny Brown

    631

  • Odd Man Out

    700

  • Le Corbeau

    730

  • Random Harvest

    740

  • The Silence of the Sea

    747

  • There Was a Father

    754

  • The Mortal Storm

    837

  • Waterloo Bridge

    860

  • Record of a Tenement Gentleman

    946

  • The Children Are Watching Us

    998

  • A Day in the Country

    1005

  • Gentleman Jim

    1041

  • Ornamental Hairpin

    1061

  • Enamorada

    1072

  • Bitter Rice

    1076

  • The Other

    1125

  • The ionate Friends

    1128

  • Jenny Lamour

    1155

  • Canyon age

    1170

  • Spring in a Small Town

    1195

  • The Clock

    1204

  • Hail the Conquering Hero

    1210

  • Brute Force

    1239

  • A Letter to Three Wives

    1374

  • The Fallen Idol

    1399

  • The 47 Ronin

    1443

  • The Little Foxes

    1464

  • Aniki-Bóbó

    1473

  • Unfaithfully Yours

    1527

  • A Canterbury Tale

    1565

  • Portrait of Jennie

    1603

  • Act of Violence

    1631

  •  the Night

    1657

  • The Big Clock

    1703

  • You’re Missing the Point

    1754

  • The More the Merrier

    1799

  • One Wonderful Sunday

    1833

  • Daisy Kenyon

    1843

  • Women of the Night

    1849

  • The Search

    1859

  • The Miracle of Morgan’s Creek

    1930

  • Criss Cross

    1938

  • Body and Soul

    1944

  • Colorado Territory

    1951

  • The Sea Wolf

    1978

  • A Hen in the Wind

    1987

  • The Last Stage

    2005

  • Thieves' Highway

    2006

  • Went the Day Well?

    2055

  • I  Mama

    2134

  • Hangover Square

    2139

  • Stormy Waters

    2159

  • Oliver Twist

    2162

  • To Each His Own

    2174

  • The Snake Pit

    2181

  • This Land Is Mine

    2188

  • All That Money Can Buy

    2192

  • Yellow Sky

    2212

  • Macbeth

    2414

  • Mrs. Miniver

    2421

  • Pursued

    2483

  • Murder, My Sweet

    2493

  • Christmas in July

    2497

  • Meet John Doe

    2629

  • Utamaro and His Five Women

    2654

  • Johnny Belinda

    2699

  • Hangmen Also Die!

    2703

  • The Devil and Miss Jones

    2758

  • Antoine & Antoinette

    2790

  • Brighton Rock

    2799

  • The Thief of Bagdad

    2812

  • The Murderer Lives at Number 21

    2858

  • Dreams That Money Can Buy

    2867

  • Obsession

    2936

  • We the Poor

    2939

  • The Mark of Zorro

    2967

  • Twelve O'Clock High

    2985

  • A Family Like Many Others

    2991

  • Humoresque

    3086

  • Heaven Can Wait

    3097

  • A Foreign Affair

    3099

  • Moonrise

    3105

  • Gaslight

    3152

  • This Happy Breed

    3242

  • A Woman's Face

    3252

  • Stormy Weather

    3291

  • Intruder in the Dust

    3331

  • Los Tres Huastecos

    3337

  • The Sea Hawk

    3341

  • The Letter

    3365

  • Objective, Burma!

    3399