Beautifully shot silent from the redoubtable Borzage. Always appreciate Gaynor’s expressive face. Farrell is such a hunk. Final scene where they make out in the snow was very sweet.

Happy for everyone who got something out of this! But…I’m not that girl. Aside from a scattering of thrilling numbers, the bulk of this feels bloated, childish & slickly corporate. It’s a Happy Meal toy of a film. And this is coming from someone who liked what Chu accomplished with In the Heights a few years back. The singing sure was beautiful, though- especially those ravishing harmonies in Defying Gravity.