Beautifully shot silent from the redoubtable Borzage. Always appreciate Gaynor’s expressive face. Farrell is such a hunk. Final scene where they make out in the snow was very sweet.

Happy for everyone who got something out of this! But…I’m not that girl. Aside from a scattering of thrilling numbers, the bulk of this feels bloated, childish & slickly corporate. It’s a Happy Meal toy of a film. And this is coming from someone who liked what Chu accomplished with In the Heights a few years back. The singing sure was beautiful, though- especially those ravishing harmonies in Defying Gravity.
“If you want to get on in this life, there are things you have to ignore.”
One of the most slept-on films of the year, this got under my skin. I’ve always loved Claire Keegan’s novels, and Mielants expertly captures the hermetic darkness she creates. Cillian Murphy continues to amaze.
Ok, Pugh and Garfield are two of the best actors of their generation, so watching them in anything is easy, but this film gets bogged down by cancer movie cliches, and I wasn’t feeling the ill-fitting humour sprinkled throughout. The best moment is Pugh bellowing, “I don’t want to just be someone’s dead fucking mum!”.